The Setting
Community hospitals are critical components of our healthcare system. However, consumers don’t generally expect community hospitals to offer world-class, award-winning, or cutting-edge care.
While it’s not unusual for “community” hospitals to evolve into true advanced care powerhouses, they remain hampered by consumers’ lingering, limited perception of them as just good for routine or emergency care. This really holds hospitals back from being recognized for their evolution and the level of care they actually offer.
We’ve worked with clients trying to evolve their hospital image for decades, so recently, when a client approached us with this question, we knew how to dive right in.
Even with decades of investments in advanced programs, state-of-the-art technology, and new facilities (which had earned them extraordinary ratings), consumers continued to see this client as a community hospital, closer in image to the 4-room hospital they started as over 100 years ago than to the regional center for advanced care they are today.
Our client and their advertising partner had set out to develop a campaign to change this image. But in order to do so, they needed to understand the consumer mindset.
Phase 1: Conducting Research
Using a combination of qualitative and quantitative research, we assessed consumers’ image of the hospital, effectively spotlighting the gaps and misconceptions that needed to be addressed.
Harnessing the expertise of the social psychologists on our team, we developed a deep understanding of what consumers needed to hear to pick our client for their care. We focused in on how our client could use this new campaign to shift their current image; what would make consumers see them as offering cutting edge, advanced care.
Key Findings
- The “community hospital” stereotype is widespread and unwavering. When thinking of our client, consumers were most likely to think about care that was good and convenient. They did not readily associate them as a place they would want to go for complex or life-threatening issues. Despite all their accomplishments, the hospital lacked an image of highly qualified physicians, innovation, visionary medicine, or specialized care.
- The campaign needed to counter these stereotypes head on. We knew this campaign needed to set a new tone for the hospital, but our research showed it needed to go beyond simply informing consumers of what the hospital offers and convincing them to see the hospital in a more positive and professional light. It needed to convey a value proposition that was ownable, differentiated them from competitors, aligned with what consumers actively valued, and elevated their image to drive more significant consideration for advanced care.
Phase 2: Developing The Campaign
Using the deep insights and guidance gleaned through phase 1 focus groups, our client and their creative team created a campaign to highlight the hospital’s strengths. To maximize potential impact and ensure that the campaign hit the mark, the client came back to us to conduct creative and messaging testing with their patient population.
This time we deployed a survey with open-ended questions and utilized advanced statistical techniques to segment reactions to creative elements by respondent characteristics such as age, income, race, and experience with the hospital. This helped our client not only understand what creative messaging would work best but narrow down to identify that audience that needed to hear it the most.
Survey respondents were asked to consider details about the content, image, headline, and different layouts/designs and how the campaign impacted their consideration of our client for an advanced or specialized health issue.
Testing Findings
- The campaign struck a note. Consumers were surprised by the level of specialized care, technology, and the number of awards our client had. And the new information definitely had a positive impact. From a statistical standpoint, the ads were effective at shifting consumers’ image of the hospital and its physicians and increasing confidence in their ability to treat advanced health issues.
- Experience mattered most. Using advanced techniques including MaxDiff, Key Driver, and segmentation analysis, we found that consumers responded best to positioning around cutting-edge technology and experienced doctors. Awards lend credibility but are not the most motivating thing to lead with for driving hospital choice.
Specific Recommendations for Success
1. Use “exceptional” thoughtfully. Consumers liked the descriptor, but they didn’t want to see wordplay for the sake of it; too much “fluff” can undermine credibility.
2. Communicate specialty service lines or areas of specialization to elevate the brand. Emphasizing areas of expertise would help consumers see why the hospital is exceptional. Highlighting excellence in a particular area can have a halo effect, elevating the brand as a whole.
3. Expand on what the hospital’s system affiliation means for consumers. This was a point of interest and surprise to some people. It was also seen as a major reason to believe in the hospital’s quality.
4. Stay up-to-date. The campaign directs consumers to the hospital website so it’s pivotal to ensure physician bios are updated, and that the website includes authentic photos and testimonials since consumers are likely to be researching providers more often than the hospital itself.
5. Show providers “in action.” Consumers are attracted to visuals that create an emotional connection with the providers and showcase them using advanced technology.
Impact
Following the deployment of the ad campaign by our client and their advertising partner, Market Street conducted a Brand Pulse study 6 months later to assess the campaign impact on the brand’s image.
Overall, we found that our client’s image for treating advanced, specialized health issues trended higher over time. This was most notably the case among those who saw their campaign.